What is the Difference Between Forging and Extrusion

Definition and Process Overview

 Smeden

Definition: Forging is a manufacturing process in which metal is shaped by compressive forces, usually applied with a hammer, press, or die.

Process:

The metal is heated to a malleable temperature (for hot forging) or processed at room temperature (for cold forging).

It is then shaped using impact or pressure to achieve the desired form.

Can be done manually (open-die forging) or with precision dies (closed-die forging).

 Extrusion

Definition: Extrusion is a manufacturing process where metal is pushed or drawn through a die to create objects with a constant cross-sectional profile.

Process:

The material is either heated (hot extrusion) or kept at room temperature (cold extrusion).

It is forced through a mold or die opening, creating a continuous shape with a uniform cross-section.

Common for producing rods, pipes, and complex profiles.

What is extruded aluminum?

Extrusion, including extruded aluminum, is a process that forms a product with a fixed cross-sectional profile over its entire length. The process starts with a fixed-shape die and a length of stock (usually a round stock) that is forced through the die to conform to its shape. This requires the stock to be larger than the shape of the die, so it is simultaneously narrowed and shaped by thick steel dies and powerful presses.

A sister process to extrusion is called “drawing,” which simply pulls the stock through the die, rather than pushing it through it. This process often limits the number of consecutive extrusion steps that can be performed quickly and is usually only used for simpler extruded shapes, such as wire and round tubes.

Extrusion can be performed on hot or cold material, but hot extrusion is essential for materials with complex shapes and drastic shape changes. Extrusion can be performed on many different types of materials and is very useful for producing tubing and small or medium-sized identical parts that can be cut from a long extruded billet. The surface finish of the extruded billet is very good, and brittle materials can be easily extruded due to the support of the die and the simple forces present during the extrusion process.

What is Forging?

Forging is the process of forming metal into a specific shape using heat and pressure, through which forging transforms the raw metal without melting it. Forging is therefore often similar to the extrusion process, but forging usually only processes one part at a time.

Forging is similar to extrusion and can include the use of multi-ton presses, but can also fall under the umbrella of hammer forging and roll forging:

Hammer forging: Hammer forging uses a powerful steam, electricity, or air pressure-driven hammer to strike the workpiece quickly and repeatedly. This can quickly reshape heavy or thick metal pieces with a smaller hammer and lower overall pressure than required with a press. However, hammer forging is only used for open-die forging.

Press forging: A press applies continuous force to the top and bottom of the material to shape it. Generally, a press requires higher power input and more pressure than a hammer but can reshape the material into a variety of shapes and has more forming capabilities than a hammer. Press forging can be used with open dies (the die does not surround the workpiece) or closed dies (the die surrounds the workpiece). Closed presses are almost always used to create parts with three-dimensional shapes.

Roll Forging: Roll forging is the process of heating a material and passing it through heavy steel rolls to reduce the size and lengthen the material. Roll forging does not necessarily produce round parts; roll forging can produce square and rectangular billets, and patterns can be added to the rolls to impart that pattern to the workpiece.

Key differences

What is the difference between forging and extrusion?

Due to the properties of aluminum, extrusion and forging can subject aluminum billets to very high stresses that other metals, such as steel, cannot withstand. Aluminum’s ductility and elasticity make it an ideal material for extrusion and forging. Aluminum can also take on more complex and extreme shapes than steel without suffering possible damage.

So what are the advantages of forged aluminum over extruded aluminum? There are two main ones:

  • Complex Forming: The disadvantage of metal extrusion is that it requires a round billet and a specific set of die standards. Creating a center hole or other closed cavity in the center of the billet requires complex tooling, and other complex shapes are impossible to extrude. In contrast, forging can easily produce these shapes with minimal complex engineering. Closed-die forging, in particular, can produce almost any shape that may be difficult to produce with extrusion. In addition, forging works in three dimensions, while extrusion only works in two dimensions, which means that angles that are impossible in extrusion can be easily produced with forging.
  • Versatility: Due to the difference in forming capabilities, extrusion is not practical for many common forms and shapes. Extrusion is suitable for long or tubular shapes that require a consistent 2D cross-sectional shape that can be cut into many parts but is not suitable for anything that requires 3D shapes or angles. Converting extruded aluminum to these shapes requires a complex post-extrusion process that nearly negates the speed gains of the extrusion process.

Extrusion is a necessary process for forming metal for specific uses. However, many of the most common applications in the aerospace industry require strong and complex parts that cannot be achieved with the extrusion process.

Feature Smeden Extrusion
Process Type
Shaping by compressive force
Shaping by pushing through a die
Material Flow
Deformation occurs by compression
Deformation occurs by flow through a die
Shape Produced
Complex,non-uniform shapes
Uniform cross-sectional shapes
Temperature
Can be hot or cold forging
Can be hot or cold extrusion
Strength
High-strength parts due to grainrefinement
Good strength but lower than forged parts
Precision
Less precise than extrusion
Highly precise and consistent cross. sections
Surface Finish
Rougher surface finish
Smoother surface finish
Less Material Waste
Less material waste
More material waste due to trimming
Applications
Gears, crankshafts, wrenches, automotive parts
Pipes, rods, tubing, and profiles

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages of Forging

  1. Improved mechanical properties: The grain structure is refined, enhancing strength and toughness.
  2. Better fatigue resistance: Ideal for load-bearing applications.
  3. Less waste: More efficient material utilization.
  4. Cost-effective for large production runs.

Disadvantages of Forging

  1. Lower precision: Requires further machining for accuracy
  2. Limited complexity: Less suitable for intricate or hollow shapes.
  3. Tooling costs: High upfront costs for dies and presses.

Advantages of Extrusion

  1. Uniform cross-sections: Ideal for continuous, complex shapes
  2. Smooth surface finish: Minimal post-processing required.
  3. High precision and consistency: Suitable for mass production
  4. Versatility: Works with metals, plastics, and composites.

Disadvantages of Extrusion

  1. Weaker mechanical properties: Weaker than forged parts.
  2. Higher material waste: Excess trimming may be necessary.
  3. Limited shape complexity: Cross-sectional profiles only.

Applications and Industry Use

Forging Applications

  • Automotive: Crankshafts, gears, and connecting rods.
  • Aerospace: Aircraft landing gear and turbine components.
  • Industrial Tools: Hammers, wrenches, and spanners.
  • Defense and Military: High-strength components for tanks and weapons.

Extrusion Applications

  • Construction: Aluminum window frames, pipes, and structural profiles.
  • Automotive: Aluminum heat exchangers and trim parts.
  • Electrical: Copper and aluminum wiring and tubing.
  • Consumer Goods: Bicycle frames, furniture components, and appliance parts.

Neem contact met ons op via e-mail op Lynnyao@prototekparts.com of bel: +86-0792-86372550

Tags:

Sociaal netwerk:

Onlangs gepost

Online hulp!

+(86) 0791-86372550

IN DETAIL WILLEN BESPREKEN

Neem nu contact op met onze consultant

nl_NLNederlands

CNC Onderdelen

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

CNC Onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

CNC Draaidelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Aansluiting

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Aansluiting

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Plating

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Plating

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Onderdelen smeden

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Anodiseren

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Industrie 

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Aluminium Basis

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Zwart anodiseren

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

Constructiecomponenten

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Gesmede onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Aluminium ring

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Zwart anodiseren

HoofdprocesSmeden + CNC

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

Aluminium Basis

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Zwart anodiseren

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

Roestvrijstalen huls

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Zwart anodiseren

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Auto Onderdelen

Flens

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Auto Airconditioning Systeem

Sensorbehuizing

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Industriële Uitrusting

Sensorbehuizing

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Industriële Uitrusting

Dieptrekken Onderdelen

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Diepe Tekening

Toepassing: Industriële Uitrusting

Condensatorbehuizing

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Industriële Uitrusting

Condensatorbehuizing

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Industriële Uitrusting

Dieptrekken Onderdelen

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Diepe Tekening

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

 

Elektronisch onderdeel

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Muffer

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Muffer

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Muffer

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Uitdrijving

Toepassing: Auto industrie

Aluminium draagtas voor kunstgebit

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Medische industrie

Condensatorbehuizing

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Koude Extrusie

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Gietproef

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

HoofdprocesGieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen flens

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Finishment:Polijsten

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Sanitair

Roestvrijstalen connectoren

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen connectoren

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen connectoren

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

HoofdprocesGieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Roestvrijstalen basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Pompbehuizing

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 

Hoofdproces: Gieten+CNC

Toepassing: Pompapparatuur

 

Gietdeel

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: Gieten & CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Gegoten onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: Gieten & CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie

 

Mouw

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Mouw

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Industriële uitrustingen

Auto Onderdelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC 

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

Flens

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: Smeden + CNC

Toepassing: Auto Airconditioning Systeem

Mouw

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Lucht- en ruimtevaartindustrie

Mouw

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC 

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC 

Toepassing: Industriële uitrusting

Basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC 

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

Flens

Materiaal: Aluminium

Hoofdproces: CNC

Toepassing: Auto aircosysteem

Bar

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing: Poedermetallurgie-industrie

Basis

Materiaal: Aluminium

Afwerking: Anodiseren

Hoofdproces: Smeden+CNC

Toepassing:Auto luchtveringssysteem

Basis

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto luchtvering

CNC Draaidelen

Materiaal: Roestvrij staal 304

Afwerking: Reiniging

Hoofdproces: CNC Draaien

Toepassing: Auto industrie